The Lancet medical journal has retracted a 2006 study that claimed a baby died from codeine passed through breast milk. The journal said omissions of toxicological data in the paper amounted to falsification. The study was authored by Gideon Koren, founder of the Motherisk drug testing lab at Toronto's Hospital for Sick Children. It had influenced global guidance on breastfeeding and pain management for nearly two decades. The retraction was announced in the journal's latest issue, set for release Nov. 21.
The journal's retraction notice stated it received the conclusion of a formal investigation from SickKids' research integrity office. The report found that authorship issues and ethical concerns could not be fairly investigated because meaningful participation from Koren was unlikely. On the allegation of omission of material toxicological data, the report concluded this omission constitutes falsification. The omitted findings left readers without the information needed to assess the publication's conclusion, the notice said. The research centred on the 2005 death of an infant in Ontario. Koren's paper asserted the baby's mother was prescribed Tylenol 3, which contains codeine and acetaminophen, and that a lethal amount of morphine passed to the infant through her milk. Koren maintained for years that the case proved maternally ingested codeine could be fatal for breastfeeding babies, despite growing skepticism from other experts.
Toronto internist and pharmacologist Dr. David Juurlink, a longtime critic, said the retraction was long overdue. "This paper is the cornerstone of an entire field of pediatric pharmacology and toxicology that, honestly, should not exist," Juurlink said. He called it a "botched" study on a coroner's investigation. "This isn't just about one mischaracterized infant death. The narrative that babies can die through opioids passed through breast milk has greatly influenced postpartum pain care," he said.
A SickKids spokesperson said the hospital takes all matters of research integrity seriously. The hospital's inquiry found that omitting the toxicological data constituted falsification under its Responsible Conduct of Research Policy. SickKids declined to provide further details, citing the confidential nature of such inquiries. The case drew years of media scrutiny and a major New Yorker investigation in January. The Lancet attached an expression of concern to the report in February after new allegations emerged. "It's surprising that it took such a long time for this to happen," Juurlink said. "Not just that it took a long time, but that it took investigative journalism to cast a light on the institutional failures that kept this paper alive for 20 years." This marks another setback for Koren, who gave up his Ontario medical licence after a career marred by scandal. His Motherisk lab, which used hair testing methods later deemed unreliable, was shut down in 2019. Those tests were used in thousands of child protection cases across Canada before a 2015 review found them inadequate.



